Skip to content

Commit

Permalink
add pimlico verifying paymaster detailed results
Browse files Browse the repository at this point in the history
  • Loading branch information
@mmv08
mmv08 committed May 28, 2024
1 parent c4b0353 commit 13048d3
Showing 1 changed file with 10 additions and 10 deletions.
20 changes: 10 additions & 10 deletions examples/4337-gas-metering/README.md
View file
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -11,7 +11,7 @@ NOTE: If you run a paymaster analysis twice or more without changing the salt fo
## Gas Usage Results

| | **With 4337?** | **Account Creation** | **Account Creation + Native Transfer** | **Native Transfer** | **Account Creation + ERC20 Transfer** | **ERC20 Transfer** | **Account Creation + ERC721 Minting** | **ERC721 Minting** |
|:----------------------------------------------------------------:|:--------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|:-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------:|
| :--------------------------------------------------------------: | :------------: | :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: | :---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------: |
| **[Without Paymaster](../../modules/4337/test/gas/Gas.spec.ts)** | Yes | 415213 | 447632 | 182081 | 426139 | 160575 | 467926 | 202374 |
| **Gelato (4337 Compatible - 1Balance)** | No | 302679 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0x1b2f743dff63dfc6e01e18623cb8d692d4a1cf206008358fac3eaf8fd5957c91)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0x1b2f743dff63dfc6e01e18623cb8d692d4a1cf206008358fac3eaf8fd5957c91/gas-usage)) | 313228 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0xddbd655b8a11cf043c535c2d6dbe14aa82925d444a0d4bb5378670993ad1862c)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0xddbd655b8a11cf043c535c2d6dbe14aa82925d444a0d4bb5378670993ad1862c/gas-usage)) | 83930 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0x162b8817fe9cbbccb905c4b51cc25cbf2625afa1e5341087a4e79b9bb6834fc6)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0x162b8817fe9cbbccb905c4b51cc25cbf2625afa1e5341087a4e79b9bb6834fc6/gas-usage)) | 315961 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0x1043acb58c89667d26360f23532d6eee4ab927b20ba37035fb3ffb8cc71c224b)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0x1043acb58c89667d26360f23532d6eee4ab927b20ba37035fb3ffb8cc71c224b/gas-usage)) | 86852 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0x6c6ccadea5e54aa47b36c603132b315f1cf15e75e96c0376a7c76ae48f69a006)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0x6c6ccadea5e54aa47b36c603132b315f1cf15e75e96c0376a7c76ae48f69a006/gas-usage)) | 345284 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0xd49b482ff37f07f12fc1688a2af33b4451d63409fe547f9cf2e660422866da3e)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0xd49b482ff37f07f12fc1688a2af33b4451d63409fe547f9cf2e660422866da3e/gas-usage)) | 116159 ([TX](https://sepolia.basescan.org/tx/0x5814be99c937b6e7386f3526fe9f11fc1bf7a21180daf66ee2e44cc1e4d0da3d)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/base-sepolia/0x5814be99c937b6e7386f3526fe9f11fc1bf7a21180daf66ee2e44cc1e4d0da3d/gas-usage)) |
| **Pimlico (USDC Paymaster)** | Yes | 506573 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0x3c6284e4df1686d699d2bc4cca04a25ecc76d68a73665ca53d466e6bd6bedf28)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0x3c6284e4df1686d699d2bc4cca04a25ecc76d68a73665ca53d466e6bd6bedf28/gas-usage)) | 511055 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0x8bc4e42b076d22e0fc3418eba40c65caab6e3a10c1fbb10cbeee4a7fbfa8b4b3)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0x8bc4e42b076d22e0fc3418eba40c65caab6e3a10c1fbb10cbeee4a7fbfa8b4b3/gas-usage)) | 199262 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0x46cdfc14649087609f69411fc41f5feb4dc23a6ea9255928b932841858e5f186)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0x46cdfc14649087609f69411fc41f5feb4dc23a6ea9255928b932841858e5f186/gas-usage)) | 514156 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0xa5cf461800341c2e9934608ff55aeda26d1a3e7da4f5bc9f3cce3fd185409623)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0xa5cf461800341c2e9934608ff55aeda26d1a3e7da4f5bc9f3cce3fd185409623/gas-usage)) | 202387 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0xdc21ae13dc92eb48851fa62f57c74f3a0085acf81343d9aaaa14fcc3c6911f91)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0xdc21ae13dc92eb48851fa62f57c74f3a0085acf81343d9aaaa14fcc3c6911f91/gas-usage)) | 543411 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0xcd6c137474be4f002822498e032ad9b78b0505bd4db495ee65fc602ec1a7f006)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0xcd6c137474be4f002822498e032ad9b78b0505bd4db495ee65fc602ec1a7f006/gas-usage)) | 231619 ([TX](https://mumbai.polygonscan.com/tx/0x31732175d3f3b35c9c2a38e841bcd485085edf79e7f3c532ec7997c4993c0192)) ([Gas](https://dashboard.tenderly.co/tx/mumbai/0x31732175d3f3b35c9c2a38e841bcd485085edf79e7f3c532ec7997c4993c0192/gas-usage)) |
Expand All @@ -35,15 +35,15 @@ NOTE: If you run a paymaster analysis twice or more without changing the salt fo

### Pimlico (Sepolia - Verifying Paymaster)

| Type | Actual Gas | handleOps | \_createSenderIfNeeded | Safe Proxy Factory | ValidateUserOp (Safe) | \_executeUserOp | executeUserOp (Safe) | execTransactionFromModule |
|------------------------------------|------------|-----------|------------------------|--------------------|-----------------------|-----------------|----------------------|---------------------------|
| Account Creation | 414071 | 415716 | 321217 | 307459 | 15100 | 14932 | 7015 | 4411 |
| Account Creation + Native Transfer | 421350 | 423087 | 321217 | 307459 | 15100 | 22303 | 14386 | 11782 |
| Native Transfer | 137723 | 97540 | NA | NA | 20588 | 24306 | 16386 | 13782 |
| Account Creation + ERC20 Transfer | 446477 | 430566 | 321236 | 307459 | 15146 | 29378 | 21415 | 18550 |
| ERC20 Transfer | 145721 | 105017 | NA | NA | 20633 | 31382 | 23415 | 20550 |
| Account Creation + ERC721 Minting | 470905 | 455150 | 321229 | 307459 | 15130 | 54097 | 46150 | 43373 |
| ERC721 Minting | 170150 | 129601 | NA | NA | 20618 | 56100 | 48150 | 45373 |
| Type | Actual Gas | handleOps | \_createSenderIfNeeded | Safe Proxy Factory | ValidateUserOp (Safe) | \_executeUserOp | executeUserOp (Safe) | execTransactionFromModule |
|------------------------------------|------------|-----------|------------------------------|--------------------|-----------------------|-----------------|----------------------|---------------------------|
| Account Creation | 414071 | 366053 | Wasn't included in the trace | 264042 | 11771 | 14542 | 6424 | 4411 |
| Account Creation + Native Transfer | 421350 | 373424 | Wasn't included in the trace | 264042 | 11771 | 21913 | 13795 | 11782 |
| Native Transfer | 137723 | 94935 | NA | NA | 15572 | 23930 | 15795 | 13782 |
| Account Creation + ERC20 Transfer | 446477 | 397746 | Wasn't included in the trace | 264042 | 11798 | 46088 | 37906 | 35650 |
| ERC20 Transfer | 145721 | 102154 | NA | NA | 15599 | 31004 | 22806 | 20550 |
| Account Creation + ERC721 Minting | 470905 | 422417 | Wasn't included in the trace | 264042 | 11789 | 70808 | 62647 | 60473 |
| ERC721 Minting | 170150 | 126826 | NA | NA | 15590 | 55724 | 47547 | 45373 |

### Alchemy (ETH from Safe)

Expand Down

0 comments on commit 13048d3

Please sign in to comment.